Skip to main content

No One Man Should Have All That Power


"Power corrupts, and absolute power corrupts absolutely." - Lord Acton

Shakespeare would have likely agreed with this statement to a slight extent. Shakespeare would have likely believed that the prospect of power, and the quest to grow one's power is what corrupts, not the power itself. Shakespeare presents this idea in many of his plays, Macbeth and Hamlet are the two I can think of offhand. In Macbeth, the idea of the quest for power corrupting an individual is easily seen through Macbeth's drive to get the crown, while ideas of power not corrupting are present through Malcolm and Macduff, one a son of Duncan, and the other a thane of Scotland. The quest for power is also present in The Lion King, which is based on the story of Hamlet, in Scar's corruption due to his greed and desire for power.

In Macbeth, corruption in the quest for power is present through the rise and fall of Macbeth, and the use of power for good is present through the story of Malcolm and Macduff. In the line where Macbeth says, "The castle of Macduff I will surprise, seize upon Fife, give to th' edge o' th' sword his wife, his babes, and all unfortunate souls that trace him in his line" (4.1.171-174). In this line, the readers see Macbeth using his newfound power as king, and using his prior murders of Duncan and Banquo as signs of his ability. He sets out to now bring his fight to Macduff's family, including women and children, showing how his murderous rampage and his fear over losing power drives him to perform terrible acts. Macbeth suspects Macduff of treachery, and even before he confirms his suspicions, he already sets out to have Macduff's family killed. This shows the reader how Macbeth's desire for power has led him to murder anyone who may jeopardize it. However, this is not Shakespeare's way of saying that power corrupts anyone who possesses it, as evidenced through the line where Malcolm states, "I am yet unknown to woman, never was forsworn, scarcely have coveted what was mine own, at no time broke my faith, would not betray the devil to his fellow, and delight no less in truth than life" (4.3.144-149). This line shows how Malcolm, another besides Macbeth in a position of power (being the son of Duncan), still maintains the virtues and values of a traditional and ideal king. Thus, based on these two quotes, it may be concluded that Shakespeare would likely have believed that the quest to take power is what corrupts, not the power itself.

Another place this corruption can be seen that I can experienced in my own life, is the story of The Lion King. In this story, the lion Scar betrays his fellow lions and teams up with the Hyenas in order to gain the title of king, even going so far to kill his brother. This story is based on the Shakespeare play of Hamlet, and is yet another example of how Shakespeare feels about the quest for power. Also in The Lion King, is the character of Mufasa, Scar's brother. Mufasa represents how a king should act. He is noble, brave, and stands up for his family and subjects. This is an example of how one can have power without it corrupting them, while Scar's quest for power corrupts him absolutely.

Comments

  1. I really like your idea of how it isn't the power itself that corrupts but it is the quest to get the power that corrupts. However, I also observed that once Macbeth gets the title of king, he becomes more reckless and abuses his power to kill everyone who stands in his way of securely keeping the throne. This is probably why, like you said, Shakespeare would partially agree to the quote. The power itself corrupts man but at the same time the quest to get the power does too. I also like your comparison to the Lion King!! It is a great example of the quest for power. Also, I did not know that Lion King was based on Hamlet, so I learnt something new too!! :) Great job!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I really enjoy the blog post this week. I like how you thought that the journey to get the power corrupts the kings. Also like how you related it back to the lion kings saying that the story of Hamlet, in Scar's corruption due to his greed and desire for power. This was near because you go into detail on how this relates to what Macbeth goes threw in getting power. I like when you said "In this story, the lion Scar betrays his fellow lions and teams up with the Hyenas in order to gain the title of king, even going so far to kill his brother." based on that you gave us some background on the story.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Is your title a reference to the Kanye West song...?

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

IOC... Easy as 123?

My IOC Preparation for the Practice IOC: Self Scoring: A: 8/10 The awareness of the text was supported by the initial summary of the story, as well as by further explanation of terms and characters in the text. Could have further explained foreshadowing in terms of the novel, in order to show that the suggested foreshadowing would prove to be accurate later in the text. The commentary does make good reference to the passage given, and the introduction of quotations and the links made between them is accurate to the text. Reference to the Aunts and their purpose is also effective, if somewhat brief in its use. B: 7/10 Not all literary terms are explicitly stated, but rather are implied through the suggestion of "speculative diction" and tone. While specific words are stated and described, they could be further stated in terms of specific literary devices incorporated into the text. The literary devices that were analyzed, such as diction and tone set by the author,...

Free(bie) as a Bird Now...

If the bad pun in the title was not enough to let you know... this is, in fact, a freebie. Nothing to see here except for this picture of an adorable Huskey eating a book... I thought it would be funny considering the context. You can find that picture here by the way if that's what you really want, or you can just look at it here. It really makes no difference either way. Since the required things are now out of the way... to whoever may be reading this, how was your weekend? Did you do anything fun? The fact that I am dragging this blog post out will tell you that today is a boring day for me. Yesterday was fun though, and so was Friday thanks for asking... Before this becomes more uncomfortable I will end this blog post here, with no clear or definitive end...

American Dream? I'm just trying to graduate...

Image source One would have thought that in roughly 100 years of history, the "American Dream" would have drastically changed. Surely, we have different ideas as a nation of what the ultimate goal for our lives should be, right? On the surface, we really have not changed much at all. If you watch television at all, you will see that many of the car commercials and vacation advertisements will show a nice nuclear family in their nice car living a nice middle-class lifestyle. Rarely do you see advertisements involving people of the extremely poor or extremely rich, with the exception of celebrity appearances for the sake of ethos. Even in commercials for luxury items, the advertisement is normally geared towards giving one the appearance of wealth, but without possessing actual wealth. This is the American Dream of today and of the 1920s, to appear as though you have wealth, and to live a wealthy lifestyle, without necessarily having to be wealthy. The ultimate...